First Importer Warning Letter Issued By FDA Citing Lack of FSVP

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is exercising its authority to enforce safe food mandates by issuing its first-ever warning letter to an importer for violation of the Foreign Supplier Verification Programs (FSVP) rule.

The federal agency delivered the warning letter to Brodt Zenatti Holdings and posted it publicly in August. The warning was issued in connection with an earlier outbreak of Salmonella Concord which, according to the Centers for Disease Control, infected six people in three states. The CDC stated that “Epidemiologic, traceback and laboratory evidence indicated that Karawan brand tahini products were likely the source of this outbreak.” The tahini products were sold under the names “Karawan Tahini”, “El-Karawan Tahini” and “Soco Tahini.”

In its warning letter to Brodt Zenatti Holdings, FDA cites the company for being non-compliant with FSVP rules saying, “You did not develop an FSVP as required by section 805 of the FD&C Act and 21 CFR part 1 subpart L. Specifically, your firm did not develop an FSVP for sesame paste tahini manufactured by Karawan Tahini and Halva in the West Bank.”

The Food Safety Modernization Act requires importers to verify that their foreign food is produced in accordance with U.S. food safety standards prior to importation. The letter to Brodt Zenatti Holdings is the first known warning letter issued to a company in violation of the FSVP requirement. An importer that receives a warning letter from the FDA must respond within 15 days and indicate corrective actions being taken.

The agency advises importers that deficiencies in FSVP compliance present a potential public health risk and that stronger enforcement measures will be implemented in serious cases of violation. Importers that previously showed serious deficiencies in inspections, or in instances where FDA may be concerned with potential health hazards due to non-compliance with FSVP, could be subject to an import alert which detains the company’s foreign food at U.S. borders without physical examination.

Importers can expect the FDA, which has largely focused on educating them about safe food regulations in recent years, will now exhibit more of its enforcement might to protect against unsafe food entering the country. FDA’s arsenal of enforcement measures includes mandatory recalls, warning letters, import alerts and increased foreign facility inspections. FDA is also enhancing its processes that detect and refuse entry of unsafe foods at U.S. borders by incorporating more advanced technology that collects data from various sources, including FSVP records, voluntary importer incentive programs, accredited third party auditors, foreign regulatory bodies and domestic supply chains.